Opening Activity
Ethical Codes and Agreements
Option A has students analyze professional codes of ethics and create dilemmas. Option B has teams debate philosophical rules and create shared agreements for meetings and competition.
High School Ethics Bowl Curriculum
Ten skill-building activities for 9th through 12th grade students practicing moral reasoning, critical thinking, case analysis, and careful dialogue.
These 10 lessons are designed to provide 9th through 12th grade students with engaging, collaborative, and rigorous activities that will strengthen their moral reasoning, critical thinking, and discussion skills. While each lesson focuses on ethics, this is not a guide on how to compete in Ethics Bowl. Instead, these lessons develop a firm foundation in the skills needed to successfully engage in dialogue and debate about ethical issues.
As such, all Ethics Bowl teams will benefit from these lessons. New teams will find introductions to key principles, moral frameworks, and reasoning skills. Returning teams will find explicit practice that goes beyond case studies and into the world of applied ethics.
These lessons feature learning outcomes that align with the Ethics Bowl competition rubric, along with foundational literacy skills needed to be successful in a competition setting. To keep things simple and functional, each lesson also comes with a short overview and a section titled, "How will this help in Ethics Bowl?" In short, these lessons will help your team...
These lessons have been designed with a gradual build of skill / complexity. For that reason, approaching the lessons in numerical order may be of value. However, many teams, especially returning teams, may find value in approaching lessons based on the team's need or interest rather than numerical order.
As a coach or facilitator, the easiest way to use the lessons is to look at the "Overview" and "Lesson Facilitation" section to understand the scope and sequence of the activities within.
Lesson library
Opening Activity
Option A has students analyze professional codes of ethics and create dilemmas. Option B has teams debate philosophical rules and create shared agreements for meetings and competition.
Frameworks
Students take a frameworks survey, compare results, and define moral principles that shape ethical decision-making.
Ethical Dilemmas
Students practice written discourse by annotating famous ethical dilemmas, then reflect on patterns in their reasoning.
Reasoning
Students critique the arguments in advertisements, name questionable reasoning patterns, and connect the work to Ethics Bowl scoring.
Evidence
Teams analyze a school newspaper dilemma, synthesize evidence, and present a supported verbal argument.
Counters
Students practice engaging alternate perspectives by treating a comments section as raw material for better counter-argument.
Stakeholders
Students rank culpability or apply moral frameworks to a case study, using tier lists as a structured discussion tool.
Presentations
Students debate speculative scenarios about technology, health care, autonomy, and freedom, then draft opening statements.
Case Writing
Students study the structure of Ethics Bowl cases and begin drafting a case for possible submission to the NHSEB case contest.
Civic Action
Students identify a community issue, analyze it through ethical frameworks, and plan a civic action or advocacy project.